My photo
I don't really care if you agree or not. Just saying what I think.

Friday, November 14, 2008

From Class This Week

Interestingly enough, class this week got into politics pretty heavy.  The class is Social Economics.  Really, really fun class. Best ever.

Here is the exchange between me and Max (my instructor)
Max..
Why Liberty?  Why is Liberty the highest, best measure for benefit? 
Why not, for example, Justice?  Why not "The Greatest Good for the Greatest Number"?
Why would you argue that Liberty should be the measure?

Me..
Because it is a right that we are endowed with "by our creator".  The basic fundamental human right is choice.  We all have it naturally.  To choose this over that, right over wrong, etc.  All of our basic human rights should first be preserved.  That is what I love so much about the Declaration of Independence.  It spells out, at the beginning, our rights as human beings.  I believe that to be true.  We all have the right to choose before we have justice.  Justice, as a right, is a result of choice not its predecessor.  Without choice, there is no right or wrong, good or evil, lightness or darkness.  Justice needs choice as we need justice.  But to have justice, we must first be able to choose.  And to be allowed to choose is liberty.  Liberty preserves our agency.  When we lose liberty, we lose our agency or choice and are beholden to the choices of our government.  Why is it better that one man or group of men make the choices for all of us?  To place trust in so few is to narrow the scope of individual needs and circumstances.  A proper choice for one may not be the proper choice for another.  

That now raises a question about our current government.  Our government here in the US is not a democracy.  Certain democratic elements are combined with the format of a republic.  We are left to choose those who will make our laws and we trust them to preserve our liberty.  John Adams once said "The proposition that the people are the best keepers of their own liberties is not true. They are the worst conceivable, they are no keepers at all; they can neither judge, act, think, or will, as a political body."  Even our founders recognized that a mob rule would ultimately fail.  Mr. Adams also said, "Democracy never lasts long. It soon wastes, exhausts and murders itself. There was never a democracy that did not commit suicide.". This sentiment buy a founder who could not conceive to trust the people too much coupled with founders like Thomas Jefferson, who in his writings seemed to err strongly on the side of democracy created a great system of government.  A system of government that holds all branches beholden to each other and all to a single constitution which guards our liberties from the choices of a few.

The problem today is that interpretations of simple words meant to safeguard our liberty our too often debated to the point where context becomes blurry.  In this case, I fear that we are losing our liberties.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment